Cobalt and the Congo: A Sustainable Green Energy Transition Cannot Be Built on Human Exploitation

General Motors, one of the United State’s most important automakers, announced in January 2021 that it would phase out petroleum-powered cars and trucks and sell only zero-emission vehicles by 2035. Although one of the auto industry’s most ambitious moves, electric vehicles (EVs) cannot be produced or driven without cobalt, we cannot discuss this ferromagnetic metal without referring to the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). The DR Congo is the world’s leading source of mined cobalt, supplying 100,000 metric tons or approximately 70% of the world cobalt mine production of 140,000 metric tons in 2019.

A piece of a 99.9 % pure plate of cobalt. Alchemist-hp via Wikimedia Commons

Cobalt is an essential component of the lithium-ion batteries that power electric vehicles. The DRC’s cobalt reserves could make it the “the Saudi Arabia of the electric vehicle age.” Despite this enormous potential, cobalt extraction in the DRC as it is carried out today comes with a hefty human, social and environmental price tag. And a cobalt boom raises the risks of numerous bad outcomes in a country like the DRC with its limited ability to govern well cobalt extraction. Creating more sustainable automobiles requires a shift in our focus beyond the policy and popular discourses about clean, green EVs, and beyond EV’s carbon emissions. Rather, creating sustainable automobiles require us to focus attention and good governance efforts along the entire EV supply chain, from extraction to end-use product.

At the raw materials input end of the supply chain for EVs, sustainability means focusing on the conditions under which cobalt is produced. The DR Congo’s natural resource wealth has made it a classic example of the resource curse, with its mineral wealth fueling and sustaining its seemingly never-ending instability and ongoing violent armed conflicts. A series of reports has shown how cobalt mining in the DR Congo is plagued by problems like human rights abuses, unsafe mining, and several other risks have been reported in the DRC cobalt mining industry. These include the use of child labor, deaths from the collapse of cobalt mines, and the environmental health risks of cobalt mining. In summary, EV have direct and indirect impacts on the physical and human security of Congolese citizens.

It is not just Congolese government officials who are responsible for ensuring that cobalt is mined in safe and just ways. Automobile companies – those using cobalt as inputs to batteries in electric vehicles – have an important role to play. Behind the increasing demand for cobalt are the companies that depend on rechargeable batteries for electric vehicles. These include almost all the large automakers that are aggressively expanding their electric vehicle lines, including Tesla, Toyota, Ford, General Motors, BMW, Volkswagen Group, and China’s leading EV company, BYD. With only about 17,000 electric cars on the world’s roads in 2010, the industry boomed during the last decade to about 7.2 million EVs on the roads in 2019 – 47% of which were in China. In the US, EV sales rose by 80 percent in 2018, driven by the market launch of the standard version of the Tesla Model 3.

EV consumers can also play a role in demanding good governance of the Congo’s cobalt resources. EV consumer demand is rising: a 2020 survey of American public opinion on EVs showed that 40% of Americans said they would buy or consider purchasing an all-electric vehicle in the future.

Neither companies nor consumers should ignore child labor and corruption problems to satisfy customer demands. Human and environmental welfare and protection should be the sacrosanct principles driving business, technological development, and scientific breakthroughs. Failing to improve cobalt mining conditions in the DR Congo is an injustice to the people in eastern DRC.

A sustainable green energy revolution cannot be built on human exploitation.

A predicted rise in electric-vehicle output is forecasted to require a gross annual cobalt production of 314,000 tons by 2030, which is roughly 224% more than production levels in 2019. This represents an incredible opportunity to turn things around in the DR Congo’s cobalt mining industry, if taken seriously. But as long as consumer demand for EVs remains high and the advancement of technologies requiring more of the silvery-blue, hard, lustrous, and brittle element are prioritized over human security and welfare, normalizing conflicts and human rights abuses will continue in the DRC’s mining industry with ripple effects across all layers of politics and communities. This is because powerful actors will continue dominating the mines, employing children, discarding workers’ concerns, and using force, including military means, to control the system with an ultimate goal of accumulating abnormal profits at the detriment of the people.

Greater transparency, although not sufficient, is required. And we need to ensure that legal regimes and the voluntary governance initiatives in the cobalt and other extractive industries are adequately addressing questions such as who should be accountable for using child labor in cobalt mines for trading in conflict-mined cobalt.

Share this: